As regular followers of this blog (yes, both of you!) will
know, I have a soft spot for books which feature alternative histories and
particularly a magical version of London. I can't recall what caused me to buy The Witches of Chiswick, probably I
thought this was a member of this sub-sub-genre but, in fact, it is rather
different – very different.
The complicated plot starts in the 23rd century,
a grossly overcrowded and dystopian London in which the hero, one Will
Starling, a young man obsessed with the Victorian age, is at work in a museum
cataloguing paintings of that era when he discovers a jarring little detail in
a portrait – the subject is wearing a digital watch. The authorities seem very
keen to destroy the painting but Will hides it, only to discover that he is
being hunted as a result. After a chain of improbable circumstances Will finds
himself transported by a time machine back to the Victorian era – but one which
is very different from that portrayed in the history books, with a far higher
level of technology.
I can't say much more without spoilers, but Will's
adventures in this strange version of Victorian London are often hilarious (the
author has a tongue-in-cheek sense of humour and the book is full of jokes),
sometimes grim as he eventually comes up against the deadly Witches of Chiswick
who are behind all of the changes.
This is a decidedly zany story with a writing style to match
(the author sometimes addresses the reader directly via footnotes – including
an apology for a really bad joke) and
at first I thought I wasn't going to like it, but I found it increasingly
difficult to put down. It certainly won't be to everyone's taste but it's worth
trying for a decidedly different reading experience.
******************************
Sadly, I could not say the same of Boneshaker by Cherie Priest, which is Book 1 of the Clockwork Century series of four novels
(to date). This "steampunk" alternative history story was highly
praised when it emerged in 2009, winning the Locus Award for best SF novel.
I've quite enjoyed most steampunk stories I've read so far, usually finding
them light and amusing entertainment but, like The Witches of Chiswick, this one was not what I expected. It is
set in a rather different late-nineteenth century Seattle which had suffered a
disaster some years previously when an automated tunnelling machine had run
wild, collapsing the foundations of the central buldings and releasing a deadly
gas which was contained only by constructing enormous walls around the centre
of the city. The main characters are the widow and teenage son of the inventor
of the machine who live grim and unhappy lives, still suffering the
consequences of the inventor's act. The son decides to try to clear his
father's name so determines to enter the closed city centre, looking for
evidence.
That's as far as I got, somewhere past page 70. This is a
very well-written book and I can understand the praise it received, but I just
found it too slow and depressing. I became more and more reluctant to pick it
up and continue reading, so decided to cut my losses and read something else
instead.